Lightroom: Tethered capture broken on OS X 10.7 (Lion)

  • 6
  • Problem
  • Updated 6 years ago
  • In Progress
  • (Edited)
I have a Canon 20D. Tethered capture was working just fine before I upgraded to Lion, but now it doesn't. A snapshot of the console log shows the detail:

Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.682 tether_canon[393:307] Received message: listDevices
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar tether_canon[393]: listDevices
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.683 tether_canon[393:307] listDevices
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar tether_canon[393]: doInitialCameraScan
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.683 tether_canon[393:307] doInitialCameraScan
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar tether_canon[393]: setCameraRef - retaining camera - new count: 2
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.685 tether_canon[393:307] setCameraRef - retaining camera - new count: 2
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar tether_canon[393]: Tether task writing message 8 to host: ok
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.686 tether_canon[393:307] Tether task writing message 8 to host: ok
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar tether_canon[393]: Received message: connectDevice
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.686 tether_canon[393:307] Received message: connectDevice
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar tether_canon[393]: connectDevice
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.687 tether_canon[393:307] connectDevice
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar tether_canon[393]: connectCamera - retaining camera - new count: 2
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: 2011-07-21 20:10:37.687 tether_canon[393:307] connectCamera - retaining camera - new count: 2
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - GetDeviceList
Jul 21 20:10:37 whitestar [0x0-0x17017].com.adobe.Lightroom3[265]: NkDriverMacOSXEntry - result(0)
Photo of Evan Van Dyke

Evan Van Dyke

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
  • frustrated

Posted 7 years ago

  • 6
Photo of Jackie Lincoln-Owyang

Jackie Lincoln-Owyang, Senior Photoshop Quality Engineering Manager

  • 8 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Evan: We are having a LR team member work with you. Thanks for your patience.
Photo of Tobias Beyerl

Tobias Beyerl

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
I have the same issue with Lightroom 3.4.1 and Camera Raw 6.4.1

After installing the Lion 10.7 Mac OS X update it is not possible to capture therered in lightroom.

My Equiment is a Canon 5D Mark 2.

When shooting with the camera the pictures are not transfered to lightroom 3.4.1.

Please help! :-)
Photo of Evan Van Dyke

Evan Van Dyke

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I look forward to hearing from a member of your LR team, then.
Photo of Becky Sowada

Becky Sowada, Adobe Employee

  • 508 Posts
  • 105 Reply Likes
Official Response
We are aware that there are some connectivity issues with Lightroom's tether capture feature after updating to Mac OS 10.6.8 or 10.7. We're working on the issue.
Photo of Evan Van Dyke

Evan Van Dyke

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
All the posted documentation was specific to Nikon cameras, with a request to report any troubles with Canon. As my EOS-20D is Canon, I wanted to do as requested. Are Canon cameras being added to the known-issue list for Lion now?
Photo of Paulo Viveiros

Paulo Viveiros

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
I am having the same issue with my 5D and thethering with Lightroom 3.
I can see the camera but I can not capture any images or change any camera settings from the thether window.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
they’ve been “aware” of these issues for months and have done exactly zero to fix the problem, besides copy and paste messages that they”re “working on the problem” or suggesting to downgrade software. Stupid. This has been an issue for 3 or more months now. This is not a lion specific problem. This is a tether problem with Lightroom.
Photo of Butch_M

Butch_M

  • 290 Posts
  • 112 Reply Likes
In reading up on the issue, I saw recommended elsewhere to quit Lr, delete the Lr preference file (com.adobe.Lightroom3.plist) in the User/Library/Preferences folder (which is hidden in Lion, simply hold down the option key when selecting Go from the Finder Menu and the Library will appear in the drop down list ....

After deleting the preference file, I worked for several hours with both D200 and D300 bodies (not at the same time) and a Macbook Pro running Lion and Lr 3.4.1without issue ....
Photo of James Kachan

James Kachan

  • 65 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
I am quite angry,
Tethering doesnt work in Lightroom with a Canon 5D

I consulted the official Adobe Lion compatibility doc
http://kb2.adobe.com/cps/905/cpsid_90...
before upgrading to Lion, and it made NO mention of issues with Canon cameras tethered into Lightroom.

This just cost me $150 on a last minuet laptop rental running snow leopard due to the NEED of tethered capture when working with art directors on set.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 134 Reply Likes
Lightroom system requirements:

http://www.adobe.com/products/photosh...

"Mac OS X v10.5 or v10.6"

Why would you upgrade to an unsupported OS if you need stuff to work?
Photo of James Kachan

James Kachan

  • 65 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Because on a page full of adobe products, written by adobe, outlining problems, it did not mention Canon cameras, it mentioned only nikons. The page mentioned only problems, so if it didnt list a problem that would affected me, one would naturally assume it was not an issue...
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 134 Reply Likes
Or not yet known or verified.
Photo of Kevin Tieskoetter

Kevin Tieskoetter

  • 44 Posts
  • 18 Reply Likes
We've found a solution to the tethering issue on 10.6.8 / 10.7 and the fix will be included in the next dot update. There were apparently changes in the USB drivers starting in 10.6.8, and, as best I can tell, the OS puts the connection to sleep after a certain period of inactivity. I'm not sure if they're doing that to reduce power consumption or some other reason, but it caused LR to lose the connection with the camera.
Photo of James Kachan

James Kachan

  • 65 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Wonderful,

however how far away is that?
Roughly a week? two weeks? a month?

Apple has made it somewhat difficult to go back to 10.6xx.
So I'd prefer to not have to go to the bother of wiping and reinstalling if I dont have to.
Photo of Scott Woodward

Scott Woodward

  • 26 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Kevin, can you elaborate on whether you've "found a solution to the tethering issue on 10.6.8/10.7" for only the problems that Canon users are experiencing OR whether your solution will also apply to the problems Nikon users are experiencing as well, as detailed by me/others on this forum at http://feedback.photoshop.com/photosh...?
Photo of Kevin Tieskoetter

Kevin Tieskoetter

  • 44 Posts
  • 18 Reply Likes
The solution affects both Canon and Nikon cameras. The problem appeared to be more widespread on Nikon for some reason.

Unfortunately, I can't comment on when the update will be available, but I'm hoping our PM can chime in here.
Photo of Clive Brooks

Clive Brooks

  • 6 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Kevin, any update on this issue?
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
it seems like you should disclose on your sales website that tether capture is not compatible at this point in time. It's not fair to have people drop $300 to find out tether wont work. This is a copy and paste from Adobe's lightroom webpage, I would say this is not a accurate statement:

Lightroom 3 contains the same features and delivers the same professional, best-of-class results, no matter which platform you choose to use.
Photo of Victoria Bampton - Lightroom Queen

Victoria Bampton - Lightroom Queen, Champion

  • 3774 Posts
  • 1249 Reply Likes
> It's not fair to have people drop $300 to find out tether wont work.
Do you usually buy software without trying a demo first? The trial has the same bug, so I'd hope that they'd discover the issue before dropping their cash, so they could make an informed decision.

I completely understand what your frustration, but it's a huge company. By the time the website department get around to updating that page, the engineers will have fixed and released an update. The fact that Kevin says they've already fixed it, suggests you shouldn't have too much longer a wait now.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 131 Reply Likes
"it seems like you should disclose on your sales website that tether capture is not compatible at this point in time."

Isn't it well-known at this point that Apple randomly breaks stuff all the time with their updates? I mean, it's been like this since the 80s. I don't see why people jump right into their updates without waiting a while (like a year) to see what the fallout is going to be.
Photo of Victoria Bampton - Lightroom Queen

Victoria Bampton - Lightroom Queen, Champion

  • 3774 Posts
  • 1249 Reply Likes
> I don't see why people jump right into their updates without waiting a while

But it's so shiny...... ;-)

The same could be said of Lightroom updates, but we recommend people update those.

I admit I no longer live on the cutting edge when it comes to OS upgrades, at least on my work machines, but 10.6.7 to 10.6.8 *should* have been a simple update. I bet you run your Windows updates too Lee Jay.

It's a pain, but it's part of choosing to live on the cutting edge - sometimes you get cut.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 131 Reply Likes
"I bet you run your Windows updates too Lee Jay. "

I didn't get XP until SP2, and I didn't get Windows 7 until three months ago, skipping Vista altogether.
Photo of Mau

Mau

  • 4 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Anyone have any idea when the dot update will be out? It seems to me this is the only solution to the tethering problem and it's been 1 month since the official response by Kevin.
Photo of Kevin Tieskoetter

Kevin Tieskoetter

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
There is already an release candidate available for Lightroom 3.5. It fixes the tethering issues for Nikon cameras, as well as for newer Canon cameras. However, much older Canon cameras (5D/20D/RebelXT) have more fundamental compatibility issues with Mac OS 10.7, and unless Canon releases new libraries for them, we probably won't be able to get them working in 10.7.
Photo of James Kachan

James Kachan

  • 61 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Is there anything we as consumers can do?
Not having tethering support is a MASSIVE issue.

I just tried to use my 5D to tether into Lightroom today and it didnt work.
Photo of Mau

Mau

  • 4 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
This is bad news then for me since I use the tethering feature quite a bit and I really don't have the resources to upgrade my 5D to a newer model.
I'll test Aperture to see if tethering works as suggested in the post below.

If so then let the conspiracy theories begin. Admittedly knowing nothing of software engineering I have to say that I'm kind of bummed that this is broken because of USB issues. USB? it just sounds ridiculous that this is the technology that's at the heart of the problem.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
The last thing in the world I wanted to do was transfer 200,000 photos from lightroom to aperture and I certainly didn't want to learn a new workflow, so I have no dog in this fight. I'm just saying, that from my experience, using aperture the last 2 weeks to tether, I haven't had a single hiccup. I've also experimented with DSLRremote Pro with a watched folder and there have been no problems. Adobe can say what they want but my opinion is that they are dead wrong on this. It's not a library problem. it's an Adobe engineering problem. The good news is that there is a lot more high end professionals that are fed up and ditching lightroom and trashing it on their blogs, so maybe Adobe will get off their vacation and do something. Of course the other side of the coin is that by the time that happens those people are not going to want to make another change back and will just vacate lightroom all together. I've also noticed that since this failure happened lightroom is now on sale for $125.00 My guess would be the reason is lightroom is no longer compatible with current versions of Apple OS, unless you're living in the technology stone ages and don't update your software. Adobe should do the right thing and offer refunds for those of us they have totally screwed over.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
why does Aperture work just fine with the 5D? If it's Canon's librarie that would imply that Canon provided the library updates to Apple to make Aperture compatible. I don't think that's the case. Canon has told me, though several layers, that their libraries are not the problem, they work, just like they do with Aperture, but the other companies like Adobe are not properly revising their software.
Photo of Chris Cox

Chris Cox

  • 20280 Posts
  • 764 Reply Likes
I don't know why either company would tell you something like that. But most likely the representatives you spoke to simply don't know better.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
or ask the guys at DSLR Remote Pro what they did, because they have their mac/canon tether capture program working 100%. And even though Capture One Pro discontinued support for the Canon 5D, the tether software still works. they just don't support it anymore.
Photo of Chris Cox

Chris Cox

  • 20280 Posts
  • 764 Reply Likes
We've asked Canon, the ones who should know...
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
where are these libraries stored within lightroom, and aperture if you know?
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
can you tell me where the libraries are stored in lightroom so i can cross check them against those in aperture to see where the difference is?
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
You have to laugh at this lie from Adobe's FAQ's:

Are the features the same in the Windows and Mac OS versions?
Yes. Lightroom 3 contains the same features and delivers the same professional, best-of-class results, no matter which platform you choose to use.

ummm "professional"... not so much. "Best of class"... what class would that be?
Photo of Mau

Mau

  • 4 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I have downloaded the Apple Aperture trial and it DOES do tethering with my 5D. Bummer. This raises some questions for me. Is Canon supplying information to Apple but not Adobe so that this functionality doesn't work in Lightroom?

Here's hoping for a clearer answer from the Adobe team. Also crossing fingers that this doesn't end up being the start of my migration process to Aperture since I really, really like Lightroom.
Photo of Bobby Carmichael

Bobby Carmichael

  • 24 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
They keep taking my comments out because I'm mad as heck at ADOBE for this failure in the tethering process by LR3. Current OSX, 3.4.1 and Nixon D3 and it doesn't work.

If I had a product that didn't work: 1. I wouldn't SELL it. 2. I'd make a BIG DEAL of fixing it 3. I wouldn't use anonymous "ADOBE" low level functionaries to suppress the problem like what is happening here. ADOBE has always been a very closed type of company and this coverup of LR3 is just disgraceful. I'm using a program called SOFORTBILD for now. I like CAPTURE ONE with all it's analysis tools. I'm waiting to be contacted by ADOBE about this... and WAITING and WAITING and WAITING.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 134 Reply Likes
It got broken in 10.6.8.

Even Apple doesn't claim Lion was just fixes. In fact, they claim over 250 new features, and it's a paid upgrade.

Yes, the last gap between when I upgraded from OS to OS with feature changes was from XP SP2 to Win 7 SP1 - about 7 years.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I'm not going to argue with you because you're clearly not knowledgeable about any of this. I said "update". Your OS is always releasing updates to fix bugs. Tether does not work in Snow Leopard which was released August of 2009. You keep talking about Lion.. this isn't a Lion issue. This is a Adobe issue.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
And your post makes no sense, you say "it got broken in 10.6.8" and then talk about how "Even Apple doesn't claim Lion was just fixes..." 10.6.8 isn't Lion. 10.6.8 is Snow Leopard.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 134 Reply Likes
Look, this worked in 10.6.7 and previous, right? So you change the OS version and now it doesn't work. So how does it make sense that Adobe broke it?

They've tried to fix whatever Apple broke and they released it in 3.5RC. They've probably worked on it more since. But 3.5 will be the first release since before 10.6.8 (released June 23 while LR 3.4.1 was released May 25). The last time Adobe released LR, it worked. Since then, Apple broke it - twice. And you are blaming Adobe for that.
Photo of Butch_M

Butch_M

  • 290 Posts
  • 112 Reply Likes
Lee Jay, while I agree with you on all your points ... Let us not forget that Lion was made available to Developers for months prior to it's release ... there should have been more than ample time for Adobe to discover that Apple had "broken" Lion much earlier in the process and work on a long term solution well before the 3.5 release candidate .... Lion was not a total surprise or kept under complete wraps from developers ... there more than an ample opportunity to prepare for it's arrival ...
Photo of Bobby Carmichael

Bobby Carmichael

  • 24 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I'm still on 10.6.8 and 3.4 and that doesn't work so it was BROKE long before Lion. My Point is simple: FIX IT AND FIX IT FAST! And quit sending apologists our way for ADOBE. ADOBE is arrogant and loosing a lot of it's cache over this issue. We PAID for this to work. It's really simple. Send out the FIXERS and show us you CARE ADOBE.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 131 Reply Likes
Stupid stuff. They obviously care or they wouldn't be in this thread, they wouldn't have sent out 3.5RC with fixes (did you even try the RC?), and they wouldn't be still seeking feedback on that RC. As for when it got broken, yes, Apple broke it in 10.6.8 which I think was the last release right before Lion, which as I said came out AFTER 3.4.1 was released.
Photo of Bobby Carmichael

Bobby Carmichael

  • 24 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
You know just went to look at APERTURE and you know what? like Scott Fischer. I'm DONE. I just don't like the ARROGANCE of ADOBE and their COVERUP of this fundamental issue with their product. You'd think that professionals would be treated well like professionals. And I don't like talking to ADOBE's OFF SHORE reps because ADOBE wants to pay their CEO more dough.
Photo of Kevin Tieskoetter

Kevin Tieskoetter

  • 44 Posts
  • 17 Reply Likes
Steve, I've never deleted any message on this board.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 134 Reply Likes
It looks like it at first, though, if you don't see the "view x more comments" link above a long line of comments.
Photo of Chris Cox

Chris Cox

  • 20280 Posts
  • 813 Reply Likes
Bobby reposted Kevin's entire reply for some odd reason -- I had to delete that because it was confusing.
Photo of Chris Cox

Chris Cox

  • 20280 Posts
  • 813 Reply Likes
Steve - all those replies about replacing the kext are about modifying (rolling back) the OS, not the applications.
Photo of Bobby Carmichael

Bobby Carmichael

  • 24 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Chris: No disrespect intended I just didn't find his thread when I went to look for it. It was a little defensive! I just want this fixed and I'm glad the software guy actually showed up to talk about it. And assure me and others it is being taken seriously. Because it is a reputation killer.
Photo of James Kachan

James Kachan

  • 65 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
It is a simple matter, Adobe, we, the users of Lightroom, need you to fix tethering, and we need it fixed quickly.

I am well aware of the problems and difficulties from both Apple and Canon and appreciate the directness from Adobe's representatives, however this is an issue, a major issue, and it needs to be resolved.

Of note, I have installed 10.6.6 on another drive, and tested that install OS with both LR 3.4.1 and 3.5 and tethering does not work. I don't know what Apple did to mess up the hardware of my machine, but I know that I cant even work around the problem like this.

A great problem.
Please Adobe, this issue is very important to professionals. We would like it solved, and solved quickly. Please do all you can to address this issue.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 134 Reply Likes
I don't have tethering for my 5D or 20D on Windows 7 64. Why not? Because Canon has never released a 64 bit driver for them. Worked flawlessly on XP through LR.

I suspect the same with 10.7. However Apple, having written the OS, may be able to modify existing drivers or write their own, whereas Adobe does not have such access.
Photo of Gary Dates

Gary Dates

  • 18 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Adobe has been writing software for the Mac for many many years. Now, all of a sudden they have been taken by surprise with Lion? Look, I don't care who caused the problem, but I do care that Adobe has stated quite clearly they will not do anything to fix it. Instead, they are simply saying that they are dropping support for the 5D. If they can arbitrarily decide to abandon the 5D, then they should refund the cost of Lightroom to all 5D owners!
Photo of Gary Dates

Gary Dates

  • 18 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
@James Kachan
Over a week ago you had asked me about Aperture and auto-advancing during tethering. Subsequently, I have discovered that if I set up a watched folder in LR, under certain conditions Aperture will not auto-advance. The problem is, it is intermittent.....sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. I've been too busy to try to find the exact conditions under which Aperture won't advance. Was wondering if you have any insight?

I'm running OS 10.6.8 on Mac Pro. I never had any of the issues that folks are reporting using 10.6.8. FYI, I am also running Aperture in Lion on a Macbook Air 11", and it seems to tether flawlessly, except for an occasional crash.
Photo of Mike Cinelli

Mike Cinelli

  • 8 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
"it seems to tether flawlessly, except for an occasional crash." Isn't that an oxymoron?
Photo of Gary Dates

Gary Dates

  • 18 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Well, yea, "flawlessly" and "occasional crash" are mutually exclusive. :)

It's a matter of degree though. An "occasional crash" I can deal with.......not working at all, which is the case with tethering my 5D in LR 3.5, is another thing entirely.
Photo of Bobby Carmichael

Bobby Carmichael

  • 24 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
James: Well said.
Bobby Carmichael
Carmichael Photography
Boulder, CO
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
If Adobe is a standup company they will offer refunds to Mac users that bought this software. It doesn't do what it said it could do.

This is not an Apple problem. This is not a Lion Problem. This started happening in Snow Leopard. Sorfortbild doesn't have this problem. Aperture doesn't have this problem. Capture One wasn't having this problem (they just dropped support for certain cameras).

I think you should refund all mac users that request a refund but at the very least refund those of us that can show a receipt proving we've had to buy professional software to replace Lightroom not that it is not a professional level solution.

I have my receipt for $199.00 for Aperture and I'm happy to forward it to Adobe as proof of replacement of lightroom and I request a refund.

There is no doubt that it is a major major major pain to transfer catalogs and switch platforms. But after sucking it up and doing it and spending a few hours on Lynda.com learning Aperture, I can say with all honesty Aperture runs circles around Lightroom. The only drawback is there are not as many plugins or web templates from 3rd party vendors. But the cataloging system and the ability to transfer in-progress catalogs between a desktop and laptop and vice versa and have it synch everything is worth the hassle of changing. The catalog structure of Aperture really makes you realize how convoluted lightroom is.
Photo of Gary Dates

Gary Dates

  • 18 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Hey Victoria, let me clarify, since you are at present being mislead. Yes, EOS Utility 2.8.1 DOES launch in Lion, but every version AFTER that doesn't. Further, even v2.8.1 doesn't support the Canon 5D in Lion. I know because I tried. So when I said EOS Utility doesn't work in Lion, I meant the latest version. It turns out v2.8.1 works with my Canon 40D, but as I said, not with my 5D.

I downloaded and tested Sorfortbild and it didn't even see my 5D. According to their website Sofortbild at present only supports Nikon cameras.
As far as Canon supporting the 5D, they are not. The fact that the 5D can tether in Aperture has nothing at all to do with whether or not Canon is supporting the camera. Kevin Tieskoetter explained in an earlier post exactly why the 5D works in Aperture.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Lee Jay, that's because the download is under Mac OSX. it's not version specific unless it's an update that is specific only to that version. You don't download for "10.7" you download the Mac OSX software/driver. 10.7 is just a version number.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 984 Posts
  • 130 Reply Likes
The current version is 3.10.2, and it has this warning under it on the Canon site:

"We have discovered a problem in the connection with cameras when using EOS Utility in Mac OS 10.6.8.
Please do not use EOS Utility if you use Mac OS 10.6.8."

And there isn't even an option for 10.7.

Maybe some version works, but that doesn't mean it's supported.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Gary, the point is that Aperture works with the Canon 5D and Sorfitbild works with the Nikon camera that no longer work with lightroom tether, so it's not a Canon issue. It's not a Nikon Issue. The only issue is that lightroom doesn't want to rewrite the code and gave no heads up notice that they were dropping support. At least Capture One did give notice.
Photo of Gary Dates

Gary Dates

  • 18 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Now you are making a completely different point. You can argue that Adobe should rewrite tethering to support the 5D. However, Canon is not officially supporting the 5D anymore either. Adobe's input in this thread has convinced me they are most likely NOT gonna get tethering working on the 5D again. Maybe Canon will make a move in that direction, but they want to sell us new cameras, so I doubt they will rethink their position either. I don't see the point in banging your head against this wall again and again. Take Adobe to court if you feel they have wronged you, or try and get a refund if you feel that strongly about it.

It sucks that the 5D won't tether in Lion. I completely get your frustration. I'm not happy about it either, but as long as I can get work done by using Aperture to tether, I'll take it. That's MY point.....I'm too busy to worry about LR and Adobe. If Aperture could do Smart Objects and had better NR I would seriously consider a switch, but once I got over being pissed about the situation, I realized that using both apps puts me at an advantage, so I decided to shut up and focus on things that matter....like shooting! :)
Photo of Eliot Wright

Eliot Wright

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
Please, oh please get support for tethered shooting with OS-X 10.7, Lightroom 3.5 and the Canon 5D. I am certain I am not the only person who would like this feature. I am the owner of the creative suite and Lightroom and very happy with it. It is upsetting that it was not supported to start with. I cannot afford to simply buy a new camera, and I love the 5D. Aperture allows for tethered capture with the 5D and OS-X 10.7 so I imagine you can solve the problem. I do not want to change software, by any means.

Thank you,

Eliot Wright

This reply was created from a merged topic originally titled
Canon 5D tethered capture with OS-X Lion and Lightroom 3.5 Failure.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 131 Reply Likes
The guy that writes the tethering in LR said this above:

"The Canon tether app won't even install on Lion, and has the same problem on 10.6.8. "

Canon abandoned owners of these cameras for Windows 64 bit a long time ago, and perhaps they have now done the same thing with Apple OS 10.6.8 and above.

There seems to be only three choices - I could go back to Windows 32 bit, you could go back to 10.6.7, or we could all hope that Canon updates their drivers/applications.
Photo of Gary Dates

Gary Dates

  • 18 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Look, Adobe is NOT going to support the Canon 5D in Lightroom on OS 10.7. The best solution is to use Aperture for tethering, and simply set up a "Watched Folder" in Lightroom. LR will automatically move the captured images from an Aperture tethered shoot into a destination folder of your choice. There is NO REASON to have to choose between LR and Aperture if you are on a Mac and want to use Lion, if you use a Watched Folder in LR. I hope that helps.
Photo of steve fischer

steve fischer

  • 43 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Gary, why bog your computer and RAM by running Aperture and Lightroom when Aperture does everything LR does and more? The ability to merge and synch libraries between multiple machines without having to export as catalog import as catalog etc. etc. is, like the author of this article says, a "game changer"
http://www.apertureexpert.com/tips/20...
Photo of Gary Dates

Gary Dates

  • 18 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Aperture does not support Smart Objects, and being able to use the "Edit In Photoshop As Smart Object" function in LR is crucial to my workflow. Plus, the fact is the noise reduction in Aperture vastly inferior to that of ACR. I have many thousands of photos cataloged in LR, and I'm simply not going to take the time to re-catalog in Aperture. For me, tethering in Aperture and setting up a Watched Folder in LR is a no-brainer. Quite honestly I was always happy with LR, but now that tethering my 5D doesn't work in LR on Lion, I am happy to use Aperture for that.......hooray that there is a solution. I really don't want to get into an Aperture vs LR debate either. Since I've been using Aperture lately, I can fully appreciate how elegant it is and I love the UI. But Aperture doesn't support Smart Objects and it's NR is inferior.....those are that facts.
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 131 Reply Likes
I wonder if an eyefi card could be used to wirelessly deposit the images directly into the LR watched folder, thus breaking the USB cord at the same time.
Photo of Anita Dennis

Anita Dennis

  • 75 Posts
  • 24 Reply Likes
Official Response
We've updated the relevant support docs to clarify the limitations of various Canon cameras with Lion:

Known issues with Adobe products on Mac OS Lion

Tethered camera support in Lightroom 3

Troubleshoot tethered capture in Lightroom
Photo of Lee Jay

Lee Jay

  • 990 Posts
  • 131 Reply Likes
"20D is not supported on Windows."

Since I've tethered my 20D through Lightroom on Windows XP, I'm not sure if this is an error or if it has changed.
Photo of Anita Dennis

Anita Dennis

  • 75 Posts
  • 24 Reply Likes
It was an error in the doc. Now fixed. Thanks, Lee Jay.
Photo of Mike Cinelli

Mike Cinelli

  • 8 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I've been following this problem for a while now and I'm still a little confused at this time. Has the tether problem for nikon been fixed in 3.5? or do I have to buy somebody's software like capture one or soforbild?
Photo of GREG NIKAS

GREG NIKAS

  • 19 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I'm using 2 Canon 5D's, 4 year old MacBook Pro with 10.6.8, LR 3.5, Camera Raw 6.5 and tether works just fine. I updated to 10.6.8 three weeks ago at an Apple store which they did for free because I said I was going to update to Lion. Looks like I'm going to stay right where I am until all the issues are resolved. So Sorry you are all having such trouble.