Photoshop: Simple double-click polygonal selection error fix

  • 1
  • Idea
  • Updated 4 months ago
  • (Edited)
It's staggering that I've been using Photoshop for so many years, and this issue hasn't been addressed. I know it causes frustration for most users. It certainly has for me on a regular basis.

Scenario: you're using the polygonal selection tool, you've painstakingly clicked around myriad curves and corners, then BOOM...the selection area closes prematurely and you have to start over. It's hard to imagine how many groans of frustration this has caused the user base over the years. How has this not been fixed?

The solution I know every single user would be happy with is painfully simple: undo. You close the path accidentally, a simple undo should return you to the point just before the path closed. Now I'm no programmer, but I have to assume this is more complicated than it sounds or you'd have already done it. Either way, please find a solution for this. It's long, long overdue.

Thanks,
Jason
Photo of Jason Brawn

Jason Brawn

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes

Posted 1 year ago

  • 1
Photo of Mark Payne

Mark Payne

  • 119 Posts
  • 95 Reply Likes
Absolutely so true, that I get a certain feeling in my stomach everytime I use the poly selection tool.

If undo is impossible, perhaps the path should start saving to it's own layer automatically. Somehow it should be addressed.
Photo of Jason Brawn

Jason Brawn

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Same here! It's like playing the kid's game Operation, where you're concentrating so hard, and just waiting for the buzzer to go off. It's the only tool in the Adobe family that induces this measure of anxiety!
Photo of Mark Payne

Mark Payne

  • 119 Posts
  • 95 Reply Likes
haha, or like stacking dominos carefully. One mis-step and all your work is poof.

I sometimes wish the selection tools could be a bit tighter, so we not have to use manual selection tools, but then I suppose anyone could do my job then!
Photo of Paddy Boocock

Paddy Boocock

  • 47 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
Yes, click that last point too hard and whoosh! all gone. Continuously save clicks to a selection layer as you go must be reasonably easy, all the points have to be being stored anyway.
Photo of Seth Shaw

Seth Shaw, Employee

  • 6 Posts
  • 6 Reply Likes
Hi Jason, 

If you were able to step backwards/undo multiple steps with the lasso tool, what would you expect to happen? Thanks for the feedback. Making a note of it and will bring it up with the team for discussion.

-Seth
(Edited)
Photo of Philip Dickson

Philip Dickson

  • 9 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
I'm just working on a complex car cut out now and in spite of proficiency with the Polygonal Lasso, have double clicked and completed a section where it's going to take me several minutes to unpick it via adding and subtracting from my erroneous selection, or about 10 minutes to redo it.   The Undo option should simply go back one step to the previous state of the selection being incomplete and at the last point clicked.    Whether each click of the polygonal lasso gets registered in the history or not doesn't matter to me, as long as I can immediately step back from a completed selection to the previous state. I know that backspace also goes back intermediate clicks for the lasso, that's why it may not be required to show each click in the history.  Possibly just a 'selection completed' line.
Photo of Stephen Nielson

Stephen Nielson, Group Product Manager

  • 32 Posts
  • 15 Reply Likes
Why not just use the Pen Tool and convert your path to a selection? That way you can preserve the history, come back at any time, as well as feather the selection.