Photoshop: Free Transform - ability to set Maintain Aspect Ratio as default

  • 30
  • Idea
  • Updated 2 months ago
  • Implemented
  • (Edited)
In Photoshop, it would be nice when "free transforming" a layer that the "maintain aspect ratio" lock button would maintain the previous setting, or some other way to set the default mode. I'm frustrated that I have to click it each time I'm resizing a bunch of items individually. Thanks.

Photo of Rocky Bomgaars

Rocky Bomgaars

  • 2 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
  • frustrated

Posted 7 years ago

  • 30
Photo of Adrien Denat

Adrien Denat

  • 1 Post
  • 3 Reply Likes
Seriously Adobe, your users are asking for this feature for 10 years... http://www.webmaster-talk.com/general...

We have to click this little button EACH TIMES we wants to resize something with fixed dimensions.
Photo of Suzanne Hemphill

Suzanne Hemphill

  • 9 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE fix this! I too have to click this dang box EVERY time I transform an object, which is many, many times a day. When does an object NOT get transformed in Photoshop and WHEN would we NOT want it to have the aspect ratio maintained?! I would have paid an upgrade price just for this ONE improvement. You could save us more time than a faster program with this fix. Please make it a priority for an update!
Photo of Chris Cox

Chris Cox

  • 20280 Posts
  • 830 Reply Likes
I was responding to specific points by Suzanne.

You may also notice that at no point did I say "no", or "that's not a good idea", or any other phrase that might in any way indicate that I don't agree with the request. I simply responded to a few issues in Suzanne's post.

Also, you really don't know my background. So setting up a straw man argument based on bad assumptions of my background really doesn't help.

(also, your prior assumptions on the complexity of code needed to implement this - are pretty far off)

It would be far more helpful to describe why you need such a feature, and how it would save time/effort. That would make it much easier for me to justify to the product managers while I'm trying to figure out how to implement it with appropriate UI and without a lot of hassle.
Photo of Markus Lankeit

Markus Lankeit

  • 5 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Dear Chris,

I'm not trying to be belligerent, but I think the reasons for why we are asking for this feature are adequately documented in this thread already. Just look at Suzanne's post, the essence of which is repeated throughout the thread. While it is true that you did not deliberately call it a bad idea, your response of using the shift-modifier has been offered a few times in the thread already. It gets a little frustrating when the nature of the request keeps getting ignored.

Since you ask for detail, I will offer you how it affects me... I use Photoshop a lot for layout tasks, and that frequently involves placing all sorts of elements (pictures, text, etc) and resizing them. 100% of the time, "resizing" means "maintain aspect ratio." My pictures are product images, which I've photographed. But the photographs typically have one item and usually are done at different times (as new product is released), so the camera setup is always different. That means I have to size-correct my images as part of doing layout, so all the items in one series that are 10" tall are actually the same final size. Similarly, other items on the page that are smaller/larger need to be proportionally adjusted. The free-transform drag to resize just doesn't work for me--I need the precision of pixels. And, yes, it is a pain to always have to check the same "maintain aspect ratio" box every time I select one of the 30-40 images on my page (multiply this by 30+ pages in my case). I can only imagine that the other commentators in this thread also find themselves constantly going back to check this box, hence their frustration.

My request is for a global preference, but you say that this is significant work. You're right that I don't know the Photoshop code base. Another poster suggested just keeping this box checked once selected, similar to how one can change the scaling from "%" to "px" and this is retained between selecting other layers. Both of these suggestions would solve the problem, which is that I have to check this same box repeatedly and often. If you can find another solution, that would be great, but let's leave shift-drag aside as it just won't do.

Feel free to contact me directly if you have any questions.

Thx.

-ml
Photo of Chris Cox

Chris Cox

  • 20280 Posts
  • 830 Reply Likes
Suzanne's post is similar to others here that are lacking in the needed details. I responded to start a conversation in order to get details.

Thank you for providing more details about your work. Yes, a photo layout workflow would involve more aspect ratio preservation than, say, a web or phone design workflow (which is more about arbitrary sized rectangles and rounded rectangles). And if you don't have preset grids/guides to follow, you would need to use numeric entry to scale the photos to all match in size.

Having the aspect ratio button sticky (like units and other items) might work - but I actually do have to take all the common workflows into consideration before making such a change. So the more we know about the workflows, the better.
Photo of jod-z

jod-z

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
Web design is arbitrary?

In my workflow, I use it all the time and the two main reasons are 1) to consistently resize things; 2) I often place a large image on a small canvas and use the numeric transform to resize (usually with the arrow keys and not numbers).
Photo of Markus Lankeit

Markus Lankeit

  • 5 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Agree with jod-z regarding web-design... I don't touch it as often, but essentially the same pain-points exist, especially when placing a large source image to a smaller canvas (typical when doing web stuff). Bottom line is that resizing almost always involves preserving the aspect ratio. The only time I do not need it is when I try to adapt backgrounds between different size media, like developing a web-banner using the background graphics from our catalog. That's really the 1% of the time I need to stretch and distort. The other 99% of the time, I always need to preserve aspect ratio.

Also, on my layout workflow, ascribing the fundamental issue to a lack of guides misses the point. Firstly, I use plenty of guides as-is. Secondly, (a) my product sizes vary between items; (b) overall sizes vary between pages; (c) grid-style layout is boring; therefore, creating a guide grid is usually not practical. Thirdly, even if I use guides, I still have to either manually check the "preserve aspect ratio" box or use the shift-modifier. The ask is that I don't have to repeatedly do this with every object I select, guides or no guides.

Thx.

-ml
Photo of grauenwölfe

grauenwölfe

  • 216 Posts
  • 81 Reply Likes
Please just add the ability to "stick" to what it was last set to, just like every other option in the program. I can't imagine why this is such an obstacle for you guys to implement.

We don't have to chose "Point Sample" and "All Layers" for example, every time we click the Eyedropper Tool. We don't have to click the "Current & Below" evey single time we use the Clone Stamp Tool. We don't have to select "Path" every single time we use the Pen Tool, and so on and so on. No, they stay what they were last set to as does every other tool option in the program. It just doesn't make any sense, who could it possibly offend to have it stay where it last was?
Photo of Hannah Nicollet

Hannah Nicollet, Quality Engineer

  • 720 Posts
  • 314 Reply Likes
Official Response
Hi Everyone,

Thank you for contributing to this discussion. Proportional transform is now the default behavior on Photoshop 20.0 with all but vector graphics. Photoshop 20.0 is available for download today. Please open the Creative Cloud app, download the update and let us know how it goes for you. If you do not see the update immediately, sign in and sign out of the Creative Cloud.

Thank you,
Hannah
(Edited)
Photo of Doug Barry-Martin

Doug Barry-Martin

  • 22 Posts
  • 15 Reply Likes
Please please give the user the ability to turn this on or off in preferences. The change to default on is totally against what I want. The standard in graphics used to be shift for contain otherwise it is free from constraint. Please follow well established conventions. The way it has been reset is counter intuitive for experienced professionals.
(Edited)
Photo of Doug Barry-Martin

Doug Barry-Martin

  • 22 Posts
  • 15 Reply Likes
Argggh! It's the same mess with the Skew tool. I use skew and Transform A LOT. Please revert to standard constrain (SHIFT to constrain, Option to 'counter constrain' etc)
Photo of Rosa

Rosa

  • 331 Posts
  • 179 Reply Likes
Me too!
Photo of Doug Barry-Martin

Doug Barry-Martin

  • 22 Posts
  • 15 Reply Likes
I was Ok staying with Photoshop and paying the subscription but with changes like this I will be considering my options.
Photo of Doug Barry-Martin

Doug Barry-Martin

  • 22 Posts
  • 15 Reply Likes
Now in  Transform holding option constrains the aspect ratio, Who the heck decided to change this convention?? It's nuts and against everything we've learned. PLEASE REVERT to SHIFT constrains. PLEASE!!!!!!
Photo of Patrick Mauldin

Patrick Mauldin

  • 1 Post
  • 8 Reply Likes
Please remove this as the *Default* behavior.
For years, every single user has muscle memory ingrained of using shift for maintaining aspect ratio. If you are going to change that, at least allow for an option to revert it as now it is very frustrating.

Also Please be CONSISTENT:
- If you scale an image, the default behavior is to maintain dimensions (shift to free transform)
If you scale a shape, the default behavior is free transform (shift to maintain dimensions)

How does that make sense? How is that useable and not confusing?
Every. Single. Other. Adobe program uses the old schema of default being to free transform and using shift to maintain dimensions. Why is Photoshop any different?

Please add a way to turn this off!
Photo of Kukurykus

Kukurykus

  • 664 Posts
  • 173 Reply Likes
You may also read posts from last few days to get answer even more than once ;)
Photo of Kukurykus

Kukurykus

  • 664 Posts
  • 173 Reply Likes
It looks like engineers working for Adobe don't test and compare anything, just follow directives without arguing, or maybe each time there are changes Adobe hires new programmers team that can do things as continuation of that someone made originaly. Something is bad-thought as in company I work for such oversights are unacceptable.
(Edited)
Photo of ezgoodnight

ezgoodnight

  • 11 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
At the very least, the workaround text file trick works out well and I can get my work done without having to deal with this big step backwards.

For others that come into this thread, here is the text content of that image so you can copy and paste what has worked for me. Hopefully the formatting will not mess up the text.

TransformProportionalScale 0

PSUserConfig.txt
Photo of Scott Schweigert

Scott Schweigert

  • 4 Posts
  • 11 Reply Likes
for SEO purposes - Here is the fix for photoshop scale proportional ratio bug
Photo of Doug Barry-Martin

Doug Barry-Martin

  • 22 Posts
  • 15 Reply Likes
ABSOLUTELY Patrick.
Please listen ADOBE!
Photo of Scott Schweigert

Scott Schweigert

  • 4 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
the new behavior is not consistent!!!! you still need to hold shift for creating shapes, - also holding alt to expand outwards equally is now broken.  is there a way to turn off this new behavior? 
Photo of Kukurykus

Kukurykus

  • 664 Posts
  • 175 Reply Likes
There's solution in previous posts of this theard that should work for you if you want to keep v20.
(Edited)
Photo of Kukurykus

Kukurykus

  • 664 Posts
  • 175 Reply Likes
That already started with CC 2018, now it's just worse continuation of lame releases.
Photo of Doug Barry-Martin

Doug Barry-Martin

  • 22 Posts
  • 15 Reply Likes
How do you uninstall CC2019 and revert to CC 2018?
Photo of Kukurykus

Kukurykus

  • 664 Posts
  • 175 Reply Likes
Use Adobe Creative Cloud application. There you can (un)instal certain version.
(Edited)
Photo of Cristen Gillespie

Cristen Gillespie

  • 1516 Posts
  • 455 Reply Likes
It's really not very obvious. On the right across from your version of CC2019 in the Creative Cloud app's Apps section, click on the disclosure triangle next to Open (or Update), and choose manage. You don't need to uninstall 2019 to install 2018 (though you can if you like). But that's where you can both choose to uninstall AND choose Other Versions, where you can reinstall 2018.
Photo of Android McGuinness

Android McGuinness

  • 1 Post
  • 5 Reply Likes
W the actual F, Adobe? I updated my CC like a good little boy and now I have this cracked-out scaling nonsense?

You mentioned the Undo changes on startup but not this? I don't even have words, I'm so pissed off about this right now, especially since I'm in the middle of a crazy last-minute deadline (communications designer, news fell into our lap this morning).
Photo of eartho

eartho

  • 875 Posts
  • 246 Reply Likes
Jeff, just a heads-up that transform/distort now requires the shift key to properly distort. I imagine that for 99% of the users, contrstrain distort is not what's wanted when invoking distort.
Photo of Scott Schweigert

Scott Schweigert

  • 4 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
holy cow -- its even worse than I thought.  Sometimes I like to stretch part of an image using the rectangular marquee tool when the image is just a TAD soo small - so Ill stretch it to the left, or up, or something like that.  one direction.   IT TRIES TO MAINTAIN ASPECT RATIO EVEN WHEN IM TRYING TO JUST STRETCH IN ONE DIRECTION!!!!!!!!

im reverting.  this is crazy. 
(Edited)
Photo of Scott Schweigert

Scott Schweigert

  • 4 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
it just doesn't make any sense - the only place this should have been a default behavior - is when you grab a CORNER.  If i grab a side transform point... why would I want the other sides to scale too! 
Photo of eartho

eartho, Champion

  • 982 Posts
  • 282 Reply Likes
yeah, it's kind of a big, giant trainwreck.
Photo of Rosa

Rosa

  • 331 Posts
  • 179 Reply Likes
I agree! Wait until you try transform/distort. . . that's my worst nightmare!
Photo of IAH1

IAH1

  • 39 Posts
  • 20 Reply Likes
Ok, is it not done just holding the shift key?
Photo of Kukurykus

Kukurykus

  • 664 Posts
  • 176 Reply Likes
I'd like to answer to you, but I just uninstalled Ps 19. I heard though there's some new logic in that.
(Edited)
Photo of Joel Sigerson

Joel Sigerson

  • 16 Posts
  • 20 Reply Likes
Marking this as "Implemented" is an insult. What was implemented was nothing like the above request, but a slipshod afterthought that nobody asked for. A muscle-memory challenging, workflow-interrupting, inconsistent and clumsy UX disaster. 

And give us more room to rotate without accidentally committing!
(Edited)
Photo of Randym

Randym

  • 3 Posts
  • 5 Reply Likes
This is seriously screwed up.  I think there's a memory issue.  After using Photoshop for awhile, free transform no longer works, even if you unclick the chain icon.  It works for awhile if I restart Photoshop, but eventually stops working.  I have 64 Gb of RAM and never had a problem with the older version of Photoshop.  

This version is pretty much unusable for me, unless I want to keep restarting Photoshop, which is a pain if I have several images open at once.
Photo of Ben

Ben

  • 39 Posts
  • 54 Reply Likes
Stupid move sorry, on so many levels.
Photo of Cheila Ferreira

Cheila Ferreira

  • 8 Posts
  • 14 Reply Likes
Come on Adobe! Do you actually have UX designers and QA? Because is just unacceptable...
People are used to the old behavior and the new one is just completely broken. The toggle "lock" button doesn't even work! The behavior is very inconsistent across Adobe products and even in Photoshop itself. Revert this and go back to the drawing board, if you think this is actually an issue. I'm sure there are better solutions.
Photo of Elizabeth Voice

Elizabeth Voice

  • 1 Post
  • 5 Reply Likes
this new update is driving me absolutely insane. 10min to figure out how to figure out how to revert to the old undo system, draw for 2 min, 15min to google why my brush is lagging, turn off ruler and draw for 5 min, 30min trying to figure out what the hell happened to the transform function. How many more more surprises are gonna trip me up? I've never had to actually look at the updated features to preform basic functions in PS. I do NOT want to have to relearn the program every time you decide to roll out an update. :/ I'm trying to get things done and it's set me back at least an hour by this point. I am so close to reverting back to the 2018 version, I don't want to learn new habits only for you to change the settings again. 
Photo of Kukurykus

Kukurykus

  • 664 Posts
  • 176 Reply Likes
Conclusion: during last 7 years users expected simple improvement, while Adobe made it own not requested way, that now it is not useful for those who did not wished that, but also all others who can't deal with and are bent to revert old behaviour. Bravo!?
(Edited)
Photo of Lloyd Williams

Lloyd Williams

  • 2 Posts
  • 4 Reply Likes
Dear Adobe,
Please fire EVERYONE involved in the Transform tool screw up & revert it to it's familiar behaviour. P.S. I also use Affinity Photo & I'm close to ditching Photoshop because of idiotic changes such as this.
Photo of mats_mono

mats_mono

  • 5 Posts
  • 8 Reply Likes
A simple "Maintain aspect ratio as default"-button would've done it. You know, to keep that little link button on by default. So easy, yet you managed to make it all way too complicated somehow. 
Photo of IAH1

IAH1

  • 39 Posts
  • 20 Reply Likes
Right, I think the keyword is "BUTTON". No deep programming, just the ability to lock the "maintain aspect ratio" button which works then for everything and can temporary reversed with Shift (in whichever state it was locked).
Photo of Liz Doran-Burke

Liz Doran-Burke

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
OMG thank you so much to that person above who said to hold down the shift key for transform.  This has been driving me insane since the new version was launched and I've almost put my fist through the screen a few times!!!  Please Adobe, revert back to users choosing when to lock and unlock the transform cause I was hitting that lock symbol and it wasn't working at all!  Thanks again above folks, my sanity has been saved because of your comment. <3