Lightroom: support for un-maximized PSDs

  • 5
  • Idea
  • Updated 6 months ago
  • Not Planned
  • (Edited)
I saw a post in 2009 about this, but nothing since. Lightroom NEEDS to support Unmaximized PSDs in some form or another. Right now they are invisible to Lightroom!

A multilayered photo file can be 200MB Un-Maximized, yet it's only 89 MB Maximized.

I'd even settle for saving a small composite image in the PSD that Lightroom can use.

As the guy said in 2009 - It's PHOTOSHOP LIGHTROOM, how can Lightroom completely ignore files native to Photoshop?
Photo of Mike Palmer

Mike Palmer

  • 7 Posts
  • 4 Reply Likes

Posted 7 years ago

  • 5
Photo of Tom Hogarty

Tom Hogarty, Lightroom Product Manager

  • 32 Posts
  • 37 Reply Likes
Mike, others, thanks for your persistence on the topic. I'll give you some background on why this functionality isn't currently on our Lightroom roadmap. At the end of the day, product development comes down to a series of prioritization decisions. While a reasonable feature request, this is one that's never made the prioritization cut. One of the initial concerns was that the code required to interpret proprietary, layered PSD files would more than double the size of the Lightroom application. That's an incredible burden to place on all customers for something requested by a fraction. The team also believes strongly in supporting standards such as XMP, DNG and TIFF. Supporting a proprietary, layered PSD file is not a path the team would prioritize above other efforts. Also keep in mind the testing efforts required every time we update the Lightroom application. (8 releases per year) Validating proprietary PSD support could be disproportionately expensive relative to the amount of value we're providing with the feature.

While none of this background decreases the validity of your request, hopefully it gives you an idea of why the functionality has yet to make it into Lightroom.

Regards,
Tom Hogarty
Adobe Systems
Photo of David Converse

David Converse

  • 277 Posts
  • 63 Reply Likes
So don't support layered files. Upon import, send the list of unsupported files to Photoshop and have Photoshop open and resave them (assuming Photoshop is installed.) See my feature idea below.
Photo of martijn Saly

martijn Saly

  • 189 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
See my comment below. You shouldn't need to bloat your storage with extra layers that describe what's already there, essentially.
Photo of Raffi Dian

Raffi Dian

  • 6 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I'm totally willing to give this idea up if they make a true Dual screen usage a prioity, and the godz willing to allow the Dev modules to be from the apps interface so we can arrange them the way each person wants to work(I understand it is setup to have a default workflow for default users).

Another wish for maybe version 7 or 8 is to have the Bridge browser integrate with the Library mode but be a seperate application. The Library app would be a hybrid catalog and broswer. Other formats that LR doesn't support would be dimmed out(perhaps have a right click for external app to launch it), But at least you would see all files without hindering the catalog. This would be a mature app. It is still in the infancy stage and that is the direction it would need to go for true saturation and growth.

Tom, Thank you for letting the reality of the situation be a bit more clear.
Photo of David Converse

David Converse

  • 277 Posts
  • 63 Reply Likes
This reply was created from a merged topic originally titled Convert unflattened PSD files on import.

Lightroom Classic will throw an error if you try to import PSD files which were saved without a flattened layer (Maximize Compatibility unchecked.) Besides being a poor design decision (can't even read Adobe's own native file format), the program offers no help beyond giving a list of unsupported files. Fixing the problem is left to the user.

Why not, if Photoshop is present on the system, have a preference to convert unsupported files in the background? Lightroom would send the list to Photoshop, Photoshop would open the files and save them with Maximize Compatibility, and Lightroom could then import them.

This seems like a fairly easy idea to implement.
Photo of martijn Saly

martijn Saly

  • 189 Posts
  • 13 Reply Likes
This is not a very good workaround. A better workaround would be to actively "use" the Photoshop engine to display the natively-unsupported items. Much like one can embed a spreadsheet in a text document, using the spreadsheet program engine to display its part.

Photoshop has that engine ready to go. Why not use it if it's there.