dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

Fri, Sep 30, 2011 6:33 AM

Under consideration

129

Photoshop: Mirror Paint/Symmetric/Seamless Tile Paint Function

Photoshop could use a interactive Mirror Paint and Seamless edge/border painting function. Painter has had this feature for about 10 years now.

Responses

This reply was created from a merged topic originally titled
Symmetry?.

Symmetry... look for Krita or other painting app that have symmetry. I'm pretty sure there is a lot of open source source code that can show you how to do it and add something similar, its been years I want this in photoshop -,- sad...

giovannyarce

4 Messages

•

122 Points

7 years ago

Wuao, 3 years ago this thread.

david_nielsen_7092181

8 Messages

•

224 Points

6 years ago

Canvas wrap and Live symmetry would be a really stunning addition. Astute Graphics has done it for Illustrator. Any chance of it it in Photoshop, 2015 release?

dramenon

Employee

•

66 Messages

•

1.7K Points

6 years ago

Shout on my Twitter @dramenon > it may help.

dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

It won't. Literally every drawing app has these functions except for Photoshop. Adobe doesn't understand how professionals use their tools.

6 years ago

dramenon

Employee

•

66 Messages

•

1.7K Points

I hope to change your mind one day.

6 years ago

dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

Well, it has been 3 years since we have been all talking about this. The users don't seem to have much of a voice.

6 years ago

dramenon

Employee

•

66 Messages

•

1.7K Points

I understand what you';re saying and I take these request very seriously. As entrust I want these things as badly as you.

Would you consider a conversation over email so that I may get your top concerns and requests? daniel at adobe dot com.

And this offer is open to anyone that wants to share that last > just use in the Subject Line something like "Ps Wishlist"

6 years ago

chris_cox_2148894

15.1K Messages

•

195.8K Points

You also might want to read the responses on the first page of this request topic.

6 years ago

dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

Yeah. It's the same ol thing. I'm sorry. You won't get 50,000 users coming on here asking for features. You know why? They have a life and professional jobs, and Adobe is notorious for poor service and implementing useless features. This is why companys like Astute graphics exist, to make actual useful tools that Adobe cannot design.

Adobe is ignoring the ask of the Video Game industry and the Movie Industry who produce graphics on a daily basis using all of the Adobe apps and 3d apps at once. This is where Adobe workflows and tools fail. This forum is exhausting and already wasted my time. You guys don't care.

6 years ago

chris_cox_2148894

15.1K Messages

•

195.8K Points

Nobody is ignoring requests. We are trying to get more information in order to justify this to our management. But we do have a lot of requests from many different customer segments, plus all the changes forced on us by OS changes (high DPI, OS bugs, new APIs) and new hardware.

Just because you didn't get your favorite feature in a particular release does not mean the request has been ignored, it just means we haven't gotten to it yet. If we get more requests for a feature, that moves it higher in the priority list and makes it more likely to happen sooner.

6 years ago

dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

I'll check back in another 3 years.

6 years ago

styrias

27 Messages

•

502 Points

Chris Cox you have been very arrogant, rude and unwelcoming in a lot of your responses to user requests.

It seems like you are a bottleneck for feature requests, as you smash a lot of very profound requests by simply not understanding what the users mean/want.
For me this becomes specially appearent in the context of digital painting/illustration.
You don't seem to understand what users from this group need and just piss them off.

We as users feel very mistreated by your way of communicating and your arrogant attiitude.

6 years ago

christoph_pfaffenbichler

Champion

•

1.7K Messages

•

25.5K Points

»We as users feel very mistreated by your way of communicating and your arrogant attiitude.«
I am a Photoshop user and I am in contrast grateful to Mr.Cox for contributing on this and other Fora and actually communicating with Photoshop users.
And I have not noticed arrogance in his posts so much as rather a commendable restraint.

6 years ago

jason_hall_6133589

2 Messages

•

80 Points

6 years ago

Id like to throw my hat in here as one of those requesting a symmetry tool feature in Photoshop! :-)

giovannyarce

4 Messages

•

122 Points

6 years ago

4 years ago...

fr_d_ric_convert

6 Messages

•

156 Points

6 years ago

Come on guys....Still not in the loop ?
I decided to moved to CLIP STUDIO PAINT EX just for this feature , since it exists and it s just fantastic .. !!

Maybe in another release ?

dustin_solomon

1 Message

•

80 Points

6 years ago

Having a toggle for texture tiling mode for layers and groups would be awesome! This is a feature I've wanted for a long time (for creating textures to use in 3D applications, matte paintings in Photoshop, and visual effects work in After Effects). There are so many uses for this and would be one more great reason for people to almost exclusively use Photoshop as their 2D image manipulation/creation software.

I just started using Krita for digital painting and they have a Wrap Around Mode. That is exactly what Photoshop needs.

dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

6 years ago

Give up man. You are beating a dead horse. They don't care and are full of excuses. I actually think it is their code, they aren't able to do it because of the way it was written. Something like this is very simple, especially since every drawing app on the planet has this feature except for Photoshop.

dramenon

Employee

•

66 Messages

•

1.7K Points

6 years ago

Actually we do care.

Don't listen to, dav3 he just likes to grumble.
:)

Dustin shoot me an email (daniel at adobe dot com) I would like to get more info from you if you want to discuss further.

fr_d_ric_convert

6 Messages

•

156 Points

6 years ago

So, do you have any news then ?

Is this functionnality (realtime symmetry, wrapping around, canvas repetition.. whatever it s called) planned ?

thanks for any feedback

dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

6 years ago

I don't like to grumble. Everyone here from Adobe has been either:

1. rude
2. acting like a know-it-all
3. or full of excuses, with no real answers for the users.

Daniel, feel fee to reply to my emails. People have been asking for these simple features for years—literally. Photoshop doesn't seem to listen to professional 3d visual effects/video game artists, illustrators or concept artists.

Frederic, if you want better drawing tools, use a better drawing program like Sketchbook pro. They are really nice, responsive and the feel/feedback is a much better experience.

earth_oliver

Champion

•

1.6K Messages

•

28.6K Points

6 years ago

"People have been asking for these simple features for years—literally."

Years? Try decades.

dramenon

Employee

•

66 Messages

•

1.7K Points

6 years ago

Companies are not allowed to specify what will be available or time frames, sorry. But I have been having a lot of conversations on this subject.

1 > Please feel free to contact me with an example of a rude employee/response. So that I may slap a wrist :)
2 > But we do know it all with regards to this product and all that entails :)
3 > I dont recall ever giving you or anyone an excuse on this matter (or others) I try to tell you straight when possible.

I have replied to your emails.

I have never discouraged others form trying other products, I still believe in Photoshop as my favorite tool despite the others on the market. And I have used them all.

Oh we listen, plenty of examples of listening and doing. We converse *continually* with a variety of creatives that provide valuable feedback on this subject and many things.

Have a nice day

dav3punk

46 Messages

•

2.3K Points

6 years ago

1 > Please feel free to contact me with an example of a rude employee/response. So that I may slap a wrist :)

>>Some of us are professional artists working and do not have time for finding these, or bothering with these forums.

2 > But we do know it all with regards to this product and all that entails :)

>> Maybe with the product, but not with the suite or needs of professionals, hence 3d even being a thought in Photoshop.

3 > I dont recall ever giving you or anyone an excuse on this matter (or others) I try to tell you straight when possible.

>> No, I just got an earful of the Adobe soapbox. Photoshop might be your favorite, but hardly represents the professional aspects of individual creative industries.

Has anyone seen Affinity? Give them a try. Their products are simple, clean and fast, not to mention cheap. They are up and coming... https://affinity.serif.com/en-us/

Adobe Photoshop Family

dav3punk

Photoshop: Mirror Paint/Symmetric/Seamless Tile Paint Function

Responses

giovannyarce

giovannyarce

david_nielsen_7092181

dramenon

dav3punk

dramenon

dav3punk

dramenon

chris_cox_2148894

dav3punk

chris_cox_2148894

dav3punk

styrias

christoph_pfaffenbichler

jason_hall_6133589

giovannyarce

fr_d_ric_convert

dustin_solomon

dav3punk

dramenon

fr_d_ric_convert

dav3punk

earth_oliver

dramenon

dav3punk

Helpful Widget

Tags