Skip to main content
Adobe Photoshop Family

9 Messages


590 Points

Sat, Nov 25, 2017 3:30 AM


Brush presets: Can't change the tool (presets locked to a particular tool)

On the whole, I'm happy with the new Brushes panel in Photoshop 2018. And I'm thrilled that all of Kyle Webster's brushes (which I'd been drooling over for years) are now included! But, thanks to one major issue, what could have been a major upgrade has become a crippling step backward in functionality:

Most brushes are locked to a particular tool.

This seems to have been a deliberate choice by the dev team, and I get why. Each tool has its own unique settings, and by making a brush tool-specific, those unique settings can be saved along with the brush. That's a great feature, but the problem is that there's no way to use these full-featured brushes with any other tools.

So now, if I want to test out different erasers, I can only use the brushes saved without tool presets (General Brushes and Legacy Brushes) and the Kyle Webster brushes saved as erasers (of which there are very few).

Please, Photoshop devs, add an easy-to-access checkbox that allows the user to either use brushes' tool presets or apply the brush to the selected tool. For instance, "Use Selected Tool" or "Use Tool Preset."

This conversation has been merged. Please refer the main conversation:


4 Messages


196 Points

3 years ago

I totally agree.  This change has completely messed up my workflow.  Before I could easily make any brush shape into a mixer or regular brush or eraser or smudge tool.  Now that process is much more difficult.  A huge amount of functionality is gone.