Skip to main content
Adobe Photoshop Family

945 Messages

 • 

16K Points

Sun, Oct 28, 2018 1:20 PM

4

Lightroom Classic: Names in face recognition not synced

The face are detected on mobile but the names are not synced with the names from desktop.

Responses

Adobe Administrator

 • 

8.2K Messages

 • 

117.8K Points

2 years ago


Correct. Face information does not sync between mobile and the Lightroom Classic desktop application. Syncing only occurs between the Lightroom CC clients (Desktop, web and device)
 

Adobe Photography Products

Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy

945 Messages

 • 

16K Points

And that is because...? Faces are in beta on mobile?

26 Messages

 • 

786 Points

I don't mind waiting for this feature but to hear an Official Rep confirm the behaviour is correct is disheartening. I agree - tell us it's Beta, tell us it's coming and I'll patiently wait for the two platforms to converge in some way someday.  The unknown future scares me and reminds me of the pain of loosing all my work when switching from Aperture to Lightroom when it was killed off.

Like Hierarchical Keyword syncing (see other threads), I'm in disbelief that there is a second implementation of face recognition. Let's face it neither interface is effortless. I've put a lot of hours into tagging faces in classic. To see this "New Feature" show up on iOS with none of the previously recognized face data is really disappointing.

945 Messages

 • 

16K Points

The two platform won’t converge, on the contrary:

Classic will remain the same with less and less upgrades. And no sync updates at all. Classic is going to die sooner or later because it does not fit CC’s business model.

CC will be improved little by little to get the most popular Classic function (maybe not all the “pro” features).

It is only my opinion, but they want to push towards CC because of the growing competition; with the raw files on their servers, it will be more difficult to switch to another software.

26 Messages

 • 

786 Points

I get it. But it doesn't explain to me why they have forsaken so much of their users data. The syncing is second rate but if a person bit the bullet and fully converted does it throw out all the Classic face tags?

I'm surprised this thread has not created more conversation. Perhaps the face feature was not that popular on Classic. It's still part of my workflow.

Champion

 • 

5.8K Messages

 • 

102.5K Points

> if a person bit the bullet and fully converted does it throw out all the Classic face tags?

Face tags do transfer through migration, just not through sync.

945 Messages

 • 

16K Points

Which, again, means it's not a technical limitation but a political decision ;)

Champion

 • 

5.8K Messages

 • 

102.5K Points

Ah, if only life was that clear cut Antoine. Most things are technically possible if you throw enough resources at them, but all resources are limited and priority decisions have to be made. That's just life.

A one-time, one-way migration is very different situation to a two-way sync Antoine, with very different amounts of engineering etc. involved, so at this time, they've made the decision to focus Classic on being a powerful desktop app and the Cloudy apps for cloud sync.

I do support the request for full sync in Classic, but the conspiracy theories aren't helping the cause...

26 Messages

 • 

786 Points

Thanks Victoria. That is great to know. When it comes to Syncing versus one time conversation I’m okay waiting as long as I see a path forward with my data. I believe someday LR CC will be the stronger product.

945 Messages

 • 

16K Points

Hi Victoria! Glad to hear you

26 Messages

 • 

786 Points

Hi Victoria, you mentioned that face tags are migrated. Do you know if the identified face region in Classic is migrated to the cc face region on CC.

When I converted from Aperture to Lightroom I lost regions but was able to have names come through as keywords. I still had to spend days identifying faces in the new software. It was a little more focused as I could narrow in on one perso. at a time but not every photo has a single person in it.

By region I mean the box around the face.

I was just disappointed when Adobe introduced another great feature in CC that may be sendinf my data and effort in Classic to the graveyard.

26 Messages

 • 

786 Points

Hi Victoria, you mentioned that face tags are migrated. Do you know if the identified face region in Classic is migrated to the cc face region on CC.

When I converted from Aperture to Lightroom I lost regions but was able to have names come through as keywords. I still had to spend days identifying faces in the new software. It was a little more focused as I could narrow in on one person at a time but not every photo has a single person in it.

By region I mean the box around the face.

I was just disappointed when Adobe introduced another great feature in CC that may be sending my data and effort in Classic to the graveyard.

Champion

 • 

5.8K Messages

 • 

102.5K Points

In migration, yes, regions too.

26 Messages

 • 

786 Points

oh awesome! Thank you.