10 Messages
•
160 Points
Lightroom Classic: (Mac) Crashes - GPU
I have a iMac (Retina 5K, 27-inch, Late 2015), 3.2 GHz Quad-Core Intel Core i5, 24 GB 1867 MHz DDR3, with AMD Radeon R9 M380 2 GB. After I installed the latest version of LRC, my computer would freeze each time I tried to make any adjustment on a photo in the Develop module. This issue would stop when I set the graphics processor to OFF in LRC.
I spent over an hour with Adobe support and they tried many things including installing and re-installing the app and starting a new catalog, and importing the contents of the old catalog to the new one. The problem persisted. In the end, the support person installed the previous version of LRC (back to 10.0) and all is fine now, with the graphics processor set again to Auto.
I hope this issue can be addressed with a fix. I don't think it is realistic for Adobe to expect that consumers need to live with this type of compatibility issues, especially when the video card is specified as compatible by Adobe.
Any feedback on this issue is welcome.
Responses
Official Solution
Rikk
Adobe Administrator
•
10.1K Messages
•
135.9K Points
3 m ago
Greetings all,
This thread is reserved for Apple Crashes due to a GPU switching issue while using Lightroom Classic. If you are seeing a Kernel Panic instead of a GPU issue called out in the Mac crash logs, you should be referencing this thread:
https://feedback.photoshop.com/conversations/lightroom-classic/lightroom-classic-mac-crashes-kernel-panic/5fcfae38f82792403a005851
The Lightroom Classic team believes they have resolved this issue and are looking for a few experiencing the failure to try a special test build to see if it resolves your issue. If you are willing to participate please indicate your willingness here and we will contact you via email.
Thank you for your patience.
(edited)
Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy
13
0
paul_mcfarlane
37 Messages
•
366 Points
4 m ago
I find exactly the same and simply reverted to 10.0. Backward step, as 10.1 was supposed to fix problems!
Paul
www.lightroomqueen.com
0
0
Victoria_Bampton_Lightroom_Queen
Champion
•
6.5K Messages
•
109.6K Points
4 m ago
Can you confirm which OS version you're using please?
Victoria Bampton a.k.a. The Lightroom Queen
www.lightroomqueen.com
Author of Adobe Lightroom Classic - The Missing FAQ and Adobe Lightroom - Edit Like a Pro books.
1
0
pericleselgreco
10 Messages
•
160 Points
4 m ago
I can also add the Camera Raw v13.1 crashes in Photoshop when I try to sharpen. Otherwise it is stable. I noticed that LRC is showing v13.0 for Camera Raw and when I looked up how to go back to earlier CR version I see that I have to install v12.3. v13.0 is not available. Can anyone confirm if I change 13.1 to 12.3 that LRC will still keep 13.0?
Thanks in advance.
1
Mphot43
22 Messages
•
316 Points
4 m ago
I had to revert to original v10 which is super slow in Library, but at least doesn't crash, develop - on latest version crashes constantly when I try to use develop module.
0
0
pericleselgreco
10 Messages
•
160 Points
4 m ago
I hope Adobe staff are looking at the numerous posts related to LRC crashing. Having said that, I don't see any acknowledgement from Adobe about these issues. Might be time to give up on Photoshop and LRC and switch to Capture One. Won't have all the functionality I need but oh well. Thankfully I don't have to make a living using this software. I am just a nobody amateur photographer!
Adobe are you out there? My monthly subscription for your thoughts!
2
0
Rikk
Adobe Administrator
•
10.1K Messages
•
135.9K Points
4 m ago
Is anyone on this thread seeing an Adobe Crash Dialog and submitting using their email address?
Or, are you seeing a Mac dialog?
Or, are you seeing no dialog?
Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy
3
0
pericleselgreco
10 Messages
•
160 Points
4 m ago
Thanks for the question Rikk. My experience is as described by Chrisb.
0
0
Chrisb
16 Messages
•
456 Points
3 m ago
@Rikk, just updated to Lightroom 10.1.1 since I was hoping that this bug is fixed. However, I still experience the problems described above. If you want me to, I could send you the Mac crash report?
2
0
tomtel
7 Messages
•
120 Points
3 m ago
Evidently I have been posting in the wrong place - was posting on an Adobe Support Community Mailer.
I have a MacPro 2013 with a 2.7 GHz 12-Core Intel Xeon E5, 64 GB RAM AMD FirePro D500 3 GB, with 1T SSB and connected Thunderbolt drives.
Since upgrading to LRC 10.1 I have had consistent system hangs when editing in LR along with colored flashing screens on occasions. I have not had system crashes since it does eventually come back - but impossible to edit with.
Downgraded to LRC 10.0 and have absolutely no problems or performance issues. LRC 10.1.1 came out and upgraded, and all started over again. Had to revert back to LRC 10.0. In the meantime CR was upgraded after I downgraded to LRC 10.0 and with work fine. Upgraded LRC to 10.1.1 and then had to downgrade back to LRC 10.0 and CR is now 13.0 - showing no upgraded to 13.1 or 13.1.1. (?? don't know why upgrade does not show anymore for CR).
I've had Adobe connect to my system and we worked for about an hour. Problems seen. "Solution" was to turn GPU which is totally impractical since response in edits was very, very slow. Move a slider and wait for response. Just not practical.
ONLY practical solution to fix issue was to downgrade back to LRC 10.0.
Based on post I have seen, a LOT of people are having the same issue on various types of systems. Common denominator is to downgrade to LRC 10.0 to be able to use LR.
As a footnote - before I forget - my catalogue is about 90K photos. Maybe 5K (?) are edited in LR heavily. One of the Adobe documents states that one should NOT do heavy editing in LR (?). With all the improvements in LRC, I thought the purpose of the product was to use it as an image catalog and editing tool (lots of great improvements in that field lately) before taking select photos to PS.
0
ChrisBoar
4 Messages
•
90 Points
3 m ago
Just to add my name to this list. Same iMac as the OP, running Mojave 10.14.6.
Crashing my Imac every few minutes. Tried all LR V10 variants. Only thing that stop the crashes is turning off the GPU, which makes LR very painful to use.
0
0
PauHStokes
8 Messages
•
100 Points
3 m ago
5
Derek Barrett
1 Message
•
64 Points
3 m ago
I have been having similar problems with 10.1 and 10.1.1. The develop module sometimes crashes the MacBook Pro.
The star rating is develop is confused, it shows the wrong number of stars for some photos.
When I move some of the develop sliders the image disappears, breaks up into quarters of solid colour, pixelates or whatever the latest aberration happens to be.
Using the radial filter or graduated filter makes the coloured “spinning wheel of delay” spin for ages.
I will revert to 10.0 now
I will not install 10.1.xxx. I will wait for 10.2
0
0
TimberLanePhoto
2 Messages
•
70 Points
3 m ago
I'm using a Mac Pro version 10.14.6 (Mojave) and Lightroom Classic version 10.1.1. When in the develop module and using the crop tool, Lightroom would lock up the entire computer and I'm unable to exit out of Lightroom or click on any other buttons within the program. I had to manually hard restart my computer to close Lightroom. This problem existed every time I tried to use the crop tool (over 10 times). I installed Lightroom version 10.1 and had the same problems. I had to go back two versions to 10.0 to be able to use Lightroom and the crop tool.
2
Chrisb
16 Messages
•
456 Points
3 m ago
@Rikk, is there any news about this issue? Any timeline?
0
0