Skip to main content
Adobe Photoshop Family

5 Messages

 • 

232 Points

Tue, Feb 13, 2018 6:19 PM

Closed

Lightroom Classic 7.1: Pick/reject flags hit both images in Compare and Survey view

A problem reported multiple times in the past has returned under v7.1 and was perpetuated into v7.2.  In Compare and Survey view, pick/reject flags hit both images, not the highlighted image.

I reported it 2 years ago (excerpt below).  Although sometimes it gets fixed, it keeps coming back.  It degrades workflow and creates a real risk of image loss.  I am reporting it again in hopes of it getting appropriate attention AND BETTER TESTING.  

Original post title:  Lightroom CC 2015.6: pick/reject flags hit both images in Compare and Survey view

"When two images are being Compared, or are displayed in Survey mode, a pick or reject flag entered for the selected image gets applied to the second image as well. I originally observed this problem 'way back with LR4, possibly earlier, and have reported it before (long ago). After being fixed, it appears to be reintroduced with a major or minor release. It considerably degrades the process of tagging images to be discarded or worked on, and creates a real risk of desired images being discarded. ...why this simple problem keeps coming back is baffling, especially because it's so easy to test."

This conversation has been merged. Please refer the main conversation:

Responses

474 Messages

 • 

10.5K Points

3 years ago

Oh, it is extremely annoying -- especially in Compare view. One thing that happens all the time is that I select one image on screen 1 (in Grid view) while I have forgotten that screen 2 is in Compare view. I then look at the keyboard, and while I am looking for the "P" key, Lightroom silently selects a (arbitrary) second image -- because there must always be at least two images selected if either screen is compare view. I then hit the "P" key (or 3, etc), and both images are changed.

I didn't know that Lightroom ever worked any other way. I have just learned to try to remember to get out of Compare view ASAP so I don't make this error.

Champion

 • 

5K Messages

 • 

91.6K Points

Merging into primary topic.

Please reference the new conversation here: Pick/reject flags hit both images in Compare and Survey view