4.5K Messages
•
76.3K Points
Mon, May 16, 2011 5:15 AM
46
Lightroom: Allow users to define custom metadata
It has come to my realization that a fair number of feature requests could be satisfied simply by allowing users to define custom metadata *without* having to install a 3rd party plugin.
All too often users want to "make notes" about a photo, or associate photos somehow, or record some photo status... Some use keywords and existing IPTC text fields as work-arounds, but what's really needed is a way for users to define custom metadata dynamically, to include types:
- Text
- Enumerated Set of Values (dropdown lists).
- Boolean (true/false)
- Date/Time
- Numeric
This can be done now with plugins like CustomMetadata (although all items are treated like text in smart collections and library filters - a sore point for me), but I think this needs to be built into Lightroom.
PS - *Please* at least fix the SDK to support all data types.
*** - Maybe an even better idea: package a Custom Metadata plugin with Lightroom, pre-installed in Lightroom, so users have the capability AND have a plugin that will also serve to break the plugin ice, so to speak.
Of course users would need to be able to manage custom metadata fields without editing lua files, but dynamic metadata definition is needed by plugins anyway...
Extra special bonus idea: Allow advanced users to use expressions to created derived metadata types, so users could create pixel-count metadata item from width x height metadata, as example. Maybe pre-program that one into the included custom-metadata plugin so users would also have a ready-made example to follow... aspect-ratio would be another popular derived item (cropped-width/cropped-height).
All too often users want to "make notes" about a photo, or associate photos somehow, or record some photo status... Some use keywords and existing IPTC text fields as work-arounds, but what's really needed is a way for users to define custom metadata dynamically, to include types:
- Text
- Enumerated Set of Values (dropdown lists).
- Boolean (true/false)
- Date/Time
- Numeric
This can be done now with plugins like CustomMetadata (although all items are treated like text in smart collections and library filters - a sore point for me), but I think this needs to be built into Lightroom.
PS - *Please* at least fix the SDK to support all data types.
*** - Maybe an even better idea: package a Custom Metadata plugin with Lightroom, pre-installed in Lightroom, so users have the capability AND have a plugin that will also serve to break the plugin ice, so to speak.
Of course users would need to be able to manage custom metadata fields without editing lua files, but dynamic metadata definition is needed by plugins anyway...
Extra special bonus idea: Allow advanced users to use expressions to created derived metadata types, so users could create pixel-count metadata item from width x height metadata, as example. Maybe pre-program that one into the included custom-metadata plugin so users would also have a ready-made example to follow... aspect-ratio would be another popular derived item (cropped-width/cropped-height).
Ideas
•
Updated
2 months ago
81
15
46
Helpful Widget
How can we improve?
Tags
metadata
custom metadata
projects
keywords
collections
plugins
sdk
Responses
walker_blackwell
7 Messages
•
230 Points
10 years ago
So I'm wondering if Adobe's already standard XMP "Custom File Info Panels" functionality will be implemented in Lightroom v4. If this is confirmed, large institutions can plan on buying Lightroom as a better (future proof) pre-upload (and personal collection) organizer for large sets of images vs Bridge as Bridge relies directly on a file system and the file system can become a very disorganized place. Also, Lightroom is less costly and more functional for Art Historians.
This has been a constant feature request since v1 in 2007. It has been 4 years. Is there a plan to add this in v4 or some functionality like it?
All the best,
Walker Blackwell
University of Vermont
Art History
This reply was created from a merged topic originally titled
Lightroom Custom Metadata Schema Support Needed.
0
brian_parker_4524761
5 Messages
•
116 Points
9 years ago
People (list type field)
Session (text field for photographers to be able to group photos without needing to put them into collections first, with the side benefit of freeing up the Keywords field for actual real keyword entries)
Client (Text field for us to be able to write in who comissioned us to take the photos)
And let us be able to create metadata filter panes for these new fields too.
This reply was created from a merged topic originally titled
New XMP metadata fields.
0
0
guy_young
3 Messages
•
154 Points
7 years ago
Lightroom custom XMP metadata field support.
Please make Lightroom 5 fully XMP compliant. I need to be able to read and write to custom XMP fields and I need it written in the XMP not just in the catalog as the current custom fields option is.
Adobe developed XMP and they haven't made their flagship photo management software fully XMP compliant.
Please add this feature to the Lightroom 5 and the SDK as I need it to satisfy the requirements of my large organisation (DoD). Currently I can do all bar 2 of my mandatory metadata fields in Lightroom. One of which isn't even a custom field, it is #121 Local Caption. I am forced to continue to use another program just for metadata (Fotostation).
0
0
jaran_gaarder_heggen
11 Messages
•
262 Points
5 years ago
You need to add full support for XMP Fields in Search and Smart Collections, so it is possible to set a criteria for all Fields (i.e. all Fields in the Location TAG).
Same with Custom XMP Fields.
It must also be possible to save custom XMP Fields to the XMP sidecar file.
0
0
phil_burton_7735307
83 Messages
•
1.6K Points
5 years ago
0
phil_burton_7735307
83 Messages
•
1.6K Points
4 years ago
There are requests on this forum going back to 2007 for custom metadata fields, per the XMP standard created by Adobe.
What is the Adobe management position on these requests? Rejected? Accepted? (When?) Under study or future consideration?
0
petermk
5 Messages
•
132 Points
4 years ago
0
d_h
10 Messages
•
258 Points
4 years ago
0
phil_burton_7735307
83 Messages
•
1.6K Points
4 years ago
1
phil_burton_7735307
83 Messages
•
1.6K Points
4 years ago
Only Photo Supreme claims any custom metadata support, and the level of support was recently downgraded to text-only fields. Jeffrey Friedl recently released a Lightroom plug-in that provides text-only custom metadata support. However, such fields cannot be written to XMP files, because of a limitation in the Adobe SDK (I believe).
In short, Lightroom's DAM is probably the best available for single-use situations. Of course, the competitive bar is pretty low.
Phil
0
0
jon_gross_hfijda3etehqj
3 Messages
•
142 Points
4 years ago
Could we please have first class metadata support, with custom fields? As libraries grow, and images are in use for all kinds of use cases, it is critical that we have metadata support to make those use cases possible and also future proof.
0
phil_burton_7735307
83 Messages
•
1.6K Points
4 years ago
0
0
jon_gross_hfijda3etehqj
3 Messages
•
142 Points
4 years ago
Is this forum even monitored, or are we just talking to ourselves?
3
0
jeffgoulden
10 Messages
•
218 Points
7 months ago
6
0
iamjwk
5 Messages
•
178 Points
2 months ago
Rob Cole's plugins (not encrypted) can be found here:
Dave Burns GitHub repositories
Jan-Willem Kruse
https://www.fotokruse.eu/
0