Skip to main content
Adobe Photoshop Family

37 Messages

 • 

776 Points

Tue, Sep 20, 2011 10:35 AM

Closed

Photoshop: Can't understand why step backward changes layer selection

Say you have 2 layers in a Photoshop document:
[] layerA
[] layerB

And you have layerB selected:

[] layerA
[] layerB < selected

Then you select layerA:

[] layerA < selected
[] layerB

Then you paint a brush stroke on LayerA

[] layerA < selected, now with one brush stroke
[] layerB

Then you undo that brush stroke. (CTL+Z)
What you get is:

[] layerA < brush stroke removed
[] layerB < selected,

It undoes not only the brush stroke but the layer selection operation.
What I'd prefer would be to end up with:

[] layerA < selected, with brush stroke removed.
[] layerB

I can't tell you how many times I've been working on an image with multiple layers, selected a new layer, painted something that I didn't like, undone that operation, and then discovered sometime later that I've been painting on the wrong layer for a while because of this behavior.

It's not a huge deal of course, and there are plenty of workarounds, but the behavior seems a bit strange and unintuitive. Lesser programs could not be bothered with such minor issues, but Photoshop, and the near pinnacle of perfection that the program represents, might have the motivation to address this tiny blemish on it's smoothly polished interface.

It's like a chip in the paint of a car. For an ordinary car, this wouldn't matter, but Photoshop is a Lamborghini, and it needs to shine.

This conversation has been merged. Please refer the main conversation:

Photoshop: Don't understand the undo/redo system

Responses

704 Messages

 • 

9.4K Points

9 years ago

Have you changed any of the default keyboard shortcuts?
I guess your on windows? What version of photoshop?



For me in cs5 using your steps and undo (Ctrl+Z) just undoes the brush stroke without switching layers.

37 Messages

 • 

776 Points

Good Point.

No, I haven't changed my shortcuts, but you did find a flaw in my post. It's only the CTL+ALT+Z that exhibits this behavior.

15.1K Messages

 • 

195.8K Points

Step Backward != Undo

Going backward in history states includes the full document state - including your layer selections.