130 Messages
•
2.8K Points
Tue, Nov 5, 2019 1:25 PM
Photoshop 2020 / ACR doesn't use edited version of my LrCC photos at opening from home screen.
This is VERY strange :

I made obvious edits on a LrCC image directly from my phone (colors/crop).
I usually open/edit from the Lr Photos tab in Ps homescreen.
I saw no difference in the home screen mosaic presentation between 2019 and 2020, but when I clicked (and noticed only later), 2020 says "opening original file", while 2019 said "opening original file + ACR".
2020 starts from original file, no Lr edits on the picture.
2019 starts from edited file from Lr.
I have not found a workaround so far.
it breaks my workflow.
I made obvious edits on a LrCC image directly from my phone (colors/crop).
I usually open/edit from the Lr Photos tab in Ps homescreen.
I saw no difference in the home screen mosaic presentation between 2019 and 2020, but when I clicked (and noticed only later), 2020 says "opening original file", while 2019 said "opening original file + ACR".
2020 starts from original file, no Lr edits on the picture.
2019 starts from edited file from Lr.
I have not found a workaround so far.
it breaks my workflow.
Problems
•
Updated
5 months ago
34
14
Helpful Widget
How can we improve?
Tags
No tags available
Responses
Johan_Elzenga
Champion
•
3.4K Messages
•
59K Points
a year ago
Johan W. Elzenga,
http://www.johanfoto.com
11
0
franck_payen
130 Messages
•
2.8K Points
10 months ago
My machine is MacOS, 10.13.6, in french.
Photoshop is now 21.1.2, the issue is still not fixed on my side.
Maybe not concerning many users, but still very painful.
10
0
john_wilson_7208631
6 Messages
•
110 Points
10 months ago
ADB-10456824-C9P4
Basic steps to re-create:
Change a LRCC raw image to B&W (easy to see that way)
Open in PS 2020 - Lightroom Photos
A full colour image appears in RAW.
Also, if you try and open as a Smart Object, with the preference set to Open as a Smart Object selected, it do not. It opens as a raster image.
So, they escalated this ticket to 2nd Level, they looked at it and came back and said, this is a design issue, and closed the ticket.
1
0
Rikk
Adobe Administrator
•
9.5K Messages
•
130.8K Points
10 months ago
Only raw?
Only DNG?
Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy
0
0
john_wilson_7208631
6 Messages
•
110 Points
10 months ago
0
0
Rikk
Adobe Administrator
•
9.5K Messages
•
130.8K Points
10 months ago
I reviewed your case notes with the agent and they do not reveal a source of nor solution to the problem. I am hoping other posters will respond with additional information that can point us toward a solution.
One question: Do you use the Raw Defaults functionality?
Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy
0
0
john_wilson_7208631
6 Messages
•
110 Points
10 months ago
0
0
franck_payen
130 Messages
•
2.8K Points
10 months ago
I selected 4 files, all with obvious white balance shifts and crop :
As expected, no "+XMP" mention :
And of course no crop or color change once opened :
0
alexandre_becquet
21 Messages
•
476 Points
10 months ago
0
0
Rikk
Adobe Administrator
•
9.5K Messages
•
130.8K Points
10 months ago
Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy
1
0
john_wilson_7208631
6 Messages
•
110 Points
10 months ago
0
0
franck_payen
130 Messages
•
2.8K Points
9 months ago
0
0
franck_payen
130 Messages
•
2.8K Points
6 months ago
0
0
pippi_6557871
1 Message
•
64 Points
5 months ago
Just searched for this because I'm seeing exactly the same. PS v 20.0.10 imports Original + ACR, whereas PS v 21.2.4 just imports Original.
Same photos, but with one version of PS I can get the edits and with the other I can't. If I export from LR to PS the edits come across but that's not really the way I want to work.
0
0