Skip to main content
Adobe Photoshop Family

4.5K Messages

 • 

76.3K Points

Wed, Apr 20, 2011 12:07 AM

Lightroom/Camera Raw: Brush Mask Option: If its not contiguous, don't select it

In the earliest days of Lr2, I tried the brush automask - mostly failed attempts, so I quit using it altogether. Tried it again when Lr3 came out - not much better...

Recently, I've been playing with the automask again to try and see if I can learn to use it better.

One problem I have:

The accumulating selection can leap across unselected territory to select bits and pieces of other stuff - not unlike a wildfire. Although this behavior is desirable sometimes, much of the time it just makes for more eraser work. I'd like a control option: if not contiguous with the rest of the mask - don't select it.

This would make it easier to paint selections when you know you want them bounded by some kind of edge.

7

Responses

946 Messages

 • 

13.8K Points

9 years ago

The magic wand tool in PS has a "contiguous" checkbox. I'm not quite sure how to implement something similar with the vector brush strokes, but it would be helpful if it could be done somehow.

4.5K Messages

 • 

76.3K Points

Yes, it would be helpful if it could be done somehow - so why didn't you vote for this idea, Lee Jay?

946 Messages

 • 

13.8K Points

I vote for my highest priority ones. Signal to noise is already too low in my opinion. That's also why I haven't started any threads myself.

513 Messages

 • 

11.1K Points

9 years ago

Good idea. I stopped using the "Auto Mask" feature as it almost never yields good results (too many "speckles"). Not sure how much more useful the auto masking would become with this. Ultimately, I think only more sophisticated selection tools would do the trick.

4.5K Messages

 • 

76.3K Points

I agree - if only incremental updates were made to the brush mask, I'd like to see this be one of them, but the brush mask really needs a complete overhaul, IMO - speckling and haloing are prohibitive for all but "dont care" photos or photos that will only be reproduced in a small form factor such that speckling and haloing will be condensed...