Skip to main content
Adobe Photoshop Family

13 Messages

 • 

456 Points

Wed, Apr 4, 2018 11:16 PM

Solved

Lightroom Classic 7.3/Camera Raw: Constrain Crop not saving in preset

I posted this on the adobe.com forums, but it may get more traction here....

Since updating to LR 7.3, all my presets were imported and can be used. But none of them allow the Constrain Crop option under Transform to be set by default.

Even if I apply my preset, click Constrain Crop and "Update with current settings" on the preset, it still doesn't re-apply.

Running Windows 10 64bit.

Responses

Official Solution

Adobe Administrator

 • 

8.2K Messages

 • 

118.3K Points

a year ago

Lightroom Classic 8.4 was released today and contained a fix for this issue. Please update to 8.4 and verify that you are no longer seeing the issue. Thank you!
 

Adobe Photography Products

Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy

Champion

 • 

5.2K Messages

 • 

93.4K Points

3 years ago

The underlying cause is that the new preset implementation, shared with Adobe Camera Raw, ignores the Constrain Crop setting in presets. This is most likely because ACR doesn't expose that setting in its user interface for some reason, and even though ACR will correctly display a LR-edited photo with the setting, ACR won't save the setting in a .xmp file.

Steps to reproduce:

1. Open a raw image in Develop.

2. In the Transform panel, click Auto and Constrain Crop.

3. In the Presets panel, create a preset, click Check None, then check Transform. Save the preset.

4. In the Presets panel, right-click the preset and do Show In Finder. 

5. Edit the preset's .xmp file and observe that the following line is incorrectly missing:

   crs:CropConstrainToWarp="1"
6. In the text editor, add that line above the other settings lines. 

7. Restart LR.

8. Apply the preset to another raw photo. Observe in the Transform panel that Constrain Crop is incorrectly unchecked. 

9. In the Transform panel, again check Constrain Crop.

10. Do Photo > Edit In > Open As Smart Object In Photoshop. Observe that the Constrain Crop setting has been observed in ACR's rendering.

11. In the ACR window, do Save Settings to save the photo's settings in a .xmp file.

12. Open the saved .xmp file in a text editor and observe that it is incorrectly missing the CropConstrainToWarp setting.

Adobe Administrator

 • 

15.1K Messages

 • 

288.3K Points

3 years ago

Thanks. I've asked engineering to take a look at this?

Sr. Product Manager, Adobe Digital Imaging

Champion

 • 

5.2K Messages

 • 

93.4K Points

Great, thanks.

1 Message

 • 

60 Points

hello, 
I still have this issue on several computers, on imacs and windows computers. 
Was a fix found ? Thx 

38 Messages

 • 

482 Points

As far as I know there is no work around for this. Also there has been no release of an update to fix this. What I am doing for now is as soon as I import my images I click on the first image in the group, click on the constrain crop check box , then go back to the grid, select all and sync all settings. This syncs that constrain crop. Then I go about my editing.

Champion

 • 

5.2K Messages

 • 

93.4K Points

I’ll be releasing a work-around script in the next few days — stay tuned.

Champion

 • 

5.2K Messages

 • 

93.4K Points

Unfortunately, a bug in LR prevents the work-around script from working. However, I'll post a workaround recipe below.

2 Messages

 • 

76 Points

Still no fix? This is ridiculous 

38 Messages

 • 

482 Points

I know there was an update a few days ago and I thought so it's definitely going to be there, there's just no way they could let this go again... They just don't care. It's got to be such a simple fix. At this point I've marked it as an internal joke at Adobe. They're probably trying to see how long they can let it go. Either way I have a fix in my workflow that takes about three seconds and I've decided to quit carrying, it's not worth it.

38 Messages

 • 

482 Points

A crazy thought here Jeffrey... instead of having them take a look at it, why don't we get them to actually fix it? Whoa, right?!? I know... it took me a few months to really kind of come to this thought myself. Anyway, there you go. I expect that should clear up the issue they were having by just looking at the problem. I look forward to the fix in the next update.

7 Messages

 • 

124 Points

2 years ago

When is this going to be fixed... I edit thousands of house photos and have to go and check the box on every one...

Champion

 • 

5.2K Messages

 • 

93.4K Points

2 years ago

To add Constrain Crop to all the selected images:

1. Select the desired images.

2. Go to Develop.

3.  Do Settings > Enable Auto Sync to turn on auto sync.

4. In the Transform panel, check Constrain Crop.

5. Very Important: Do Settings > Enable Auto Sync again to turn off auto sync. Forgetting to turn of auto sync can lead to disastrous accidental changes to all the selected photos.

Champion

 • 

5.2K Messages

 • 

93.4K Points

2 years ago

Another workaround: Use the Set Constrain Crop On command of the free plugin Fix Presets.

57 Messages

 • 

830 Points

2 years ago

It hasn't been fixed for 7.4 either. I am using Constrain Crop in the Lens Correction panel and it won't save in Presets either.

38 Messages

 • 

482 Points

2 years ago

How they have not fixed this is beyond me. It cannot be that complicated. I have adjusted my workflow now to where it's only taking an extra 10 seconds once I import. But things like this are just ridiculous and unacceptable for a product of this caliber. Or maybe it's not as high caliber is I am assuming...

Adobe Administrator

 • 

8.2K Messages

 • 

118.3K Points

2 years ago

Update: the issue is still open in our system and we have escalated with development.  Thank you for your patience.
 

Adobe Photography Products

Quality Engineering - Customer Advocacy

38 Messages

 • 

482 Points

Seriously Rick it's been 5 months. How can somebody not fix this in like one cup of coffee worth of editing? Disappointing to say the least from you guys

6 Messages

 • 

136 Points

I installed 8.3 and this is still broken.  This is now May 2019.  Tick, tock.

7 Messages

 • 

124 Points

2 years ago

I am still having to check this box for every photo that I edit. I edit houses.... this is creating a lot more unnecessary work. When will this be fixed? There was just an update... I was hoping it would be corrected but no... nothing. It use to work! This is so frustrating.!

38 Messages

 • 

482 Points

2 years ago

Apparently this can only be fixed with raw materials recovered from the future Mars mission.  I have given up caring.  Likely so have Adobe!

32 Messages

 • 

852 Points

2 years ago

Please, god please fix this. It really shouldn't be a difficult fix and it's a massive pain and creates tons of unnecessary work and has been going on for years.

57 Messages

 • 

830 Points

2 years ago

YES, YES, PLEASE FIX THIS!!!!!

21 Messages

 • 

550 Points

2 years ago

8 months to fix a simple bug. Why am I paying for this?

38 Messages

 • 

482 Points

2 years ago

Sadly, probably why the rest of us are. Because it's pretty damn cheap for really good software that they seem to not care about. They'd rather show a new feature that's bugged and sell to some new people.